How to Read a Diamond Grading Report, Section by Section

A grading report packs a lot of information onto a single page, and most of it is written in shorthand. Once you know how to read a diamond grading report, though, it becomes the most useful tool you have for comparing stones and confirming you are getting what you pay for. This walkthrough goes section by section, in roughly the order you will see things on reports from major labs such as GIA and IGI.

Quick answer: To read a diamond grading report, start with the report number and verify it on the lab’s website, then check that the shape, measurements and carat weight match the stone. Next review color, clarity, cut, polish, symmetry and fluorescence, and finish with the proportions, clarity plot, comments, inscription and natural or lab-grown origin.

Identification: report number, date, shape and cutting style

The top of the report identifies the stone.

  • Report number. A unique number for this diamond. It is the key you will use to verify the report online and to match the laser inscription on the stone.
  • Date. When the diamond was graded. An older date is not a problem in itself, but a stone could have been damaged or recut since then.
  • Shape and cutting style. For example, “Round Brilliant” or “Cushion Modified Brilliant.” Shape is the outline; cutting style describes the facet arrangement. Two cushions can look quite different depending on the style.
  • Measurements. Given in millimeters. For a round, you will see minimum diameter – maximum diameter × depth (for example, 6.42 – 6.45 × 3.98 mm). For fancy shapes, it is length × width × depth.

Measurements matter more than many people realize. They tell you how big the stone will look face up, and they are a practical way to confirm that the diamond in your hand is the one on the paper.

For a round, the gap between the minimum and maximum diameter also hints at how round the outline is. A difference of a few hundredths of a millimeter is normal; a large gap means the stone is slightly out of round, which is worth noting if you plan a snug bezel or halo.

The grading results: carat, color, clarity and cut

This is the part most shoppers look at first. For a refresher on what each factor means, see our guide to the 4 Cs of diamonds.

  • Carat weight. Reported to the hundredth of a carat (one carat equals 200 milligrams). It is weight, not size.
  • Color grade. On the D-to-Z scale for white diamonds, with D being colorless. Fancy colored diamonds use a different description, such as “Fancy Intense Yellow.” Details are in our diamond color scale guide.
  • Clarity grade. From Flawless (FL) to Included (I3), judged under 10× magnification.
  • Cut grade. For standard round brilliants, labs assign an overall cut grade such as Excellent, Very Good or Good. Many fancy shapes do not receive an overall cut grade on GIA reports, so you rely on proportions, polish, symmetry and visual assessment instead.

Want to see your ring before you decide? Book a Virtual Appointment

Finish and fluorescence: polish, symmetry and glow

Below the main grades you will find additional characteristics:

  • Polish describes the smoothness of the facet surfaces.
  • Symmetry describes how precisely the facets are shaped and aligned.
  • Fluorescence describes the strength (None to Very Strong) and color of any glow under long-wave UV light. For most stones it has no visible effect in normal lighting.

Polish and symmetry are usually graded on the same Excellent-to-Poor scale. Excellent or Very Good is typical for well-made stones; lower grades are worth a closer look rather than an automatic rejection.

A common mix-up is to read Excellent polish and Excellent symmetry as if they were the cut grade. They are not. On a round brilliant, the cut grade appears separately in the grading results, and it considers proportions and light performance as well as finish.

The proportions diagram

Many reports include a side-view profile of the diamond with percentages and angles. This is where you find:

  • Table % – the width of the top facet relative to the diameter.
  • Total depth % – the height of the stone relative to its diameter.
  • Crown and pavilion angles – the slope of the top and bottom portions.
  • Girdle thickness – described in words, such as “Medium to Slightly Thick.”
  • Culet – the tip at the bottom, often listed as “None.”

These numbers help explain why two stones with the same cut grade can look slightly different. They are also a useful screening tool for fancy shapes that lack an overall cut grade. Our article on diamond cut grades shows how proportions relate to sparkle.

The clarity plot, key to symbols and comments

This is the section where people who rarely read a diamond grading report tend to skim, and it is worth slowing down. Most full reports include a diagram of the diamond, seen from the top and bottom, with marks showing the type and location of inclusions. A key to symbols explains them: crystal, feather, cloud, needle, indented natural and so on. Red symbols generally indicate internal characteristics, green ones external.

The plot is very helpful for two reasons. First, it tells you where an inclusion sits. A small feather near the girdle may be hidden by a prong, while one under the table is more visible. Second, it gives you a map you can check against magnified photos or video.

The comments section deserves careful reading. Here a lab may note things like “Clouds are not shown,” “Additional pinpoints are not shown,” or details of the inscription. Comments can also flag treatments. GIA explains the kinds of diamond treatments labs look for and disclose.

Quick reference: what each line tells you

Once you have been through a report once, this summary makes the next one much faster to scan:

Report line What it tells you What to check
Report number The stone’s unique ID at that lab Matches the online record and the girdle inscription
Measurements Face-up size and depth in mm Matches the stone; sensible for the carat weight
Color and clarity Tint and inclusions on standard scales Fits your priorities; inclusions placed where they will not show
Cut grade (rounds) Overall light performance and proportions Excellent or Very Good as a sensible baseline
Polish and symmetry Finish quality of the facets Not confused with the cut grade
Fluorescence Glow under UV light Strong levels viewed in daylight
Comments Extra notes, treatments, unshown inclusions Read every word

A few red flags deserve a pause: measurements that do not match the stone, a report number that does not appear on the lab’s website, a comment noting a treatment the seller did not mention, or a “certificate” issued by the seller rather than an independent lab. None of these always means something is wrong, but each one is a reason to ask questions before you pay.

Inscription, lab-grown disclosure and verification

Laser inscription. If the girdle is inscribed, the report notes what it says, typically the report number. It is microscopic, so you will need a loupe or your jeweler’s help to read it.

Lab-grown disclosure. A report for a laboratory-grown diamond states clearly that the diamond is lab-grown, and many also note the growth method and any post-growth treatment. The inscription on lab-grown stones usually includes a lab-grown designation too. The FTC’s Jewelry Guides set out how the word diamond may be used and how lab-created stones must be described; see 16 CFR 23.12. If you are weighing both origins, our lab-grown vs natural diamond comparison covers the differences.

Verification. Always look up the report number on the lab’s own website. GIA offers Report Check, and IGI has a verification page. Make sure the online record matches the paper and the stone, especially measurements and carat weight.

A quick checklist when you read a diamond grading report:

  1. Verify the report number on the lab’s website.
  2. Confirm the shape, measurements and carat weight match the stone.
  3. Review color, clarity and, for rounds, the cut grade.
  4. Check polish, symmetry and fluorescence.
  5. Scan the proportions for anything unusually deep or shallow.
  6. Study the clarity plot and read every comment.
  7. Confirm the inscription and the natural or lab-grown origin.

If anything is unclear, ask. You can go over any report, line by line, with a jeweler during a virtual appointment, and compare it with the stone on video at the same time.

Frequently asked questions

Is a diamond grading report the same as an appraisal?

No. A grading report describes a diamond’s characteristics. An appraisal estimates a monetary value, usually for insurance. They serve different purposes, and many owners have both.

Why does my fancy-shape diamond have no cut grade?

Major labs typically assign an overall cut grade only to standard round brilliants. For other shapes, use polish, symmetry, proportions and how the stone looks.

What does “clouds are not shown” mean?

It means the stone has cloud-like clusters of tiny inclusions that are not drawn on the plot. They are often harmless, but in some stones they can affect transparency, so look at the diamond or a good video.

Can I verify an old report?

Usually yes, through the lab’s website using the report number. If the stone has been worn for years, a jeweler can check it for chips or wear that the original report would not reflect.

Do lab-grown diamond reports look different?

The layout is often similar, but a lab-grown report clearly states that the diamond is laboratory-grown and may list the growth method and any post-growth treatment. Some labs use a different document design or color for lab-grown stones.

What should I do if the report and the stone do not match?

Do not complete the purchase until the difference is explained. Ask the seller to have the stone checked against the report by a gemologist, and verify the report number on the lab’s website yourself.